Do they charge for an estimate?

Yes, $60 per estimate. Multiple reviews note competitors in the area provide free quotes.

Are they available on weekends?

Their Google listing shows they operate 7 days a week, though recent no-show reviews raise questions about actual availability.

Do they work on specialty roofs like cedar or slate?

Yes; multiple reviews document work on cedar, slate, and flat roofs, with positive feedback on specialty repairs.

The Roof Whisperer of Newmarket - Roof Repair & Skylight Contractor

Updated 2026-09-25 · 19,386 reviewed · 1,323 listed · Scored from 31 Google reviews · How we rank ›

4.6(31) 68 composite score See reviews on Google ✓ Google-verified

Roof RepairMetal RoofingFlat & Commercial RoofingRoof Inspection & Maintenance24/7 Emergency RoofingSkylight ContractorInsulation ContractorWaterproofing ServiceRoof Replacement & InstallationGutter ServiceEavestrough & GuttersSiding ContractorResidential RoofingSheet Metal ContractorRoofing ContractorChimney Services

Google-verified31 Google reviews

The Roof Whisperer of Newmarket - Roof Repair & Skylight Contractor

Services: Roof Repair, Metal Roofing, Flat & Commercial Roofing
Reviews: 31
Ranking: #570 in Roof Repair
Best for: Homeowners with cedar or slate roofs needing specialty repair or skylight installation, if communication issues resolve.

Core details are sourced from this business's Google Business Profile (checked 2026-09-25).

What do recent reviews say?

The crew delivers skilled work on specialty roofs and skylight installations when jobs proceed, with reviewers praising punctuality and clean finishes on cedar, slate, and flat roofs. However, two recent one-star reviews document a no-show appointment with no follow-up and a repair that was completed poorly with unauthorized work and permanent damage to brick facing. The owner, Arthur, charges $60 per estimate (competitors charge nothing) and has reportedly called customers to harass them over negative reviews.

Skylight work stands out as a consistent strength: multiple reviewers cite precise sealing and improved light quality. The backlog of positive reviews from 9-11 months ago contrasts sharply with the recent downward shift. A prospective customer should expect either excellent work on specialty roofs or an encounter with unavailability, poor follow-through, and dismissive communication.

Praised for

punctual and courteous crew
skilled work on specialty roofs (cedar, slate)
skylight repairs done cleanly
clear communication on jobs completed
attention to detail and precision

Watch-outs

no-show or unresponsive on scheduled appointments
poor communication and unavailable owner
unauthorized work and poor craftsmanship on repairs
estimates carry $60 fee while competitors charge nothing
owner confrontational with customers

punctualskilled-workmanshippoor-communicationno-showshoddy-workmanshipdamaged-property

Best for: Homeowners with cedar or slate roofs needing specialty repair or skylight installation, if communication issues resolve.

Think twice if: Applicant should prepare for potential no-shows, unresponsive follow-up, and expect a $60 estimate fee. Recent reviews hint at deteriorating reliability and quality control.

What are they good at?

Specializes in cedar and slate roof repairs
Skylight repair and installation with attention to sealing
Fast turnaround on completed jobs
Crew explains work clearly

Worth knowing

Owner is named Arthur
Charges $60 for estimate (competitors in area offer free quotes)
Recent no-show on scheduled roof inspection with no follow-up communication
Unauthorized masonry work on one repair damaged brick facing
Warranty promises reportedly unfulfilled; customer escalated to BBB and CRA

What reviews say by service

Skylight Contractor: Multiple reviews praise precise sealing and professional installation; no leaks reported.
Roof Repair: Strong work on cedar and slate roofs; recent review documents poor flashing repair and unauthorized brick patching.
Flat & Commercial Roofing: One review praised flat roof replacement completed on time and professionally.
Roof Inspection & Maintenance: Recent no-show with no follow-up communication undermines category credibility.
Chimney Services: One positive review noted quick chimney crack repair handled with care.

How it compares

Rated 4.6 against a 4.61 average across the 1084 skylight contractor businesses listed here.
Has more Google reviews than 73% of the businesses in this directory.

How we scored this

Ranking Method

Star rating 74

Review volume 65

Review recency 100

Review sentiment 48

Profile completeness 75

Verification 30

Rating breakdown

FAQ

Do they charge for an estimate?: Yes, $60 per estimate. Multiple reviews note competitors in the area provide free quotes.
Are they available on weekends?: Their Google listing shows they operate 7 days a week, though recent no-show reviews raise questions about actual availability.
Do they work on specialty roofs like cedar or slate?: Yes; multiple reviews document work on cedar, slate, and flat roofs, with positive feedback on specialty repairs.

Request a quote

Similar roofing contractors nearby

Calder Contracting - Roofing & Renovations Newmarket

5.0(49)✓ Google-verified

Calder responds within hours and often completes jobs the same day. Their team arrives on time, finishes efficiently with quality materials, and leaves no mess. James communicates throughout via photos and regular updates, pricing stays competitive against other quotes, and reviewers consistently praise the professionalism and reliability. The business handles gutters, eavestroughs, roof repairs, replacements, and soffit work with equal care. Crew members are friendly and straightforward about what work is needed rather than upselling extras. Kitchen renovations and fence repairs also appear in their portfolio. No negative experiences appear in recent reviews.

Roof RepairFlat & Commercial RoofingRoof Inspection & Maintenance

View profile

28 low data

Dillon Bros Roofing

No rating yet✓ Google-verified

No individual customer reviews are available for this business. Their website lists 25 years of operation and Duradek dealer certifications; they cover Newmarket, York Region, Durham, and surrounding areas.

Roof RepairMetal RoofingFlat & Commercial Roofing

View profile