The Roof Technician Toronto vs High Skillz Roofing: flat & commercial roofing compared
Both of these Ontario contractors are genuine options for flat and commercial roofing, and both carry strong track records, but the two crews built their reputations on different strengths. This comparison uses our methodology to weigh the review data against what a flat or commercial job actually demands: leak diagnosis on low-slope systems, material handling, and turnaround time.
The differences that matter
- Chronic leak diagnosis. The Roof Technician Toronto is specifically praised for finding chronic leak sources on flat roofs that other roofers missed, a skill directly tied to commercial and flat roofing troubleshooting; High Skillz's praise centers more on replacement speed and cleanup.
- Specialty material handling. The Roof Technician Toronto's crew is called out for careful work with specialty materials like slate, suggesting more comfort with varied roofing systems beyond standard asphalt shingle jobs.
- Speed on large jobs. High Skillz is noted for completing full roof replacements in a single day with a crew that works through summer heat without slowing down, a plus for larger commercial-scale jobs on a tight schedule.
- Review volume and score. High Skillz edges ahead on composite score (94.4 vs 92.9) and has more reviews (208 vs 149), both rated 5 stars, though the gap is thin and both sit in the high-confidence range.
- Owner involvement. Both businesses are described as having hands-on, direct leadership (Ilir at The Roof Technician, Arthur at High Skillz) with honest pricing and no upselling.
Side by side
- Google rating
- The Roof Technician: 5 (128 reviews)
- High Skillz Roofing Inc.: 5 (213 reviews)
- Services
- The Roof Technician: roof inspection maintenance, roofing contractor, roof replacement installation, siding contractor
- High Skillz Roofing Inc.: roof inspection maintenance, roofing contractor, roof replacement installation, siding contractor
- Best for persistent/hard-to-find leaks
- The Roof Technician: Strong fit, explicitly praised for catching chronic leaks other roofers missed
- High Skillz Roofing Inc.: Not specifically noted for this in the data
- Best for fast, large-scale replacement
- The Roof Technician: Not specifically noted for this in the data
- High Skillz Roofing Inc.: Strong fit, single-day full roof replacements and heavy-workload endurance
- Specialty/complex materials
- The Roof Technician: Called out for slate and other specialty work
- High Skillz Roofing Inc.: No specific mention of specialty materials
- Verification
- The Roof Technician: Google-verified
- High Skillz Roofing Inc.: Google-verified
- Composite score
- The Roof Technician: 92
- High Skillz Roofing Inc.: 94
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
The Roof Technician
Etobicoke-based roofing crew known for answering calls within hours and arriving the next day. Ilir, the owner, manages jobs personally and his crew (including brother Novi) handles everything from emergency shingle repairs to full roof replacements and complex multi-part projects, with no upselling and pricing that consistently comes in as the most reasonable quote homeowners receive. Work holds up: flat roof leaks stay fixed, skylights stay sealed, slate repairs last, and crews leave sites spotless.
Customers return repeatedly for quality that's visible in the installation (matched flashings, proper membrane integration, careful slate matching) and often learned the hard way by taking their third roof leak to them after two prior contractors failed. Post-job follow-up is rare in the industry and they do it. Service covers greater Toronto area including Etobicoke, The Beaches, and North York.
High Skillz Roofing Inc.
Arthur and his team consistently respond fast to urgent leaks and complete jobs the same day or next day, with crews arriving on time, explaining work clearly, and leaving sites spotless. They handle skylight leaks, metal roof installations, flat roof replacements, and emergency storm damage with equal care, backed by fair pricing and follow-up photos that give homeowners confidence in the work.
Which should you pick?
Pick The Roof Technician if
- Your flat roof has a leak that previous contractors couldn't pin down
- The job involves specialty materials like slate alongside standard flat roofing
- You want a crew known for thorough follow-up after the repair is done
Pick High Skillz Roofing Inc. if
- You need a large commercial roof replacement done fast, ideally in a single day
- You want a crew that works reliably through tough summer conditions without slowdowns
- You're weighing review volume and composite score as a tiebreaker
Verdict
Pick based on the nature of the job, not the small gap in scores. If the project is about tracking down a stubborn leak on an existing flat roof or working with less common materials, The Roof Technician Toronto's track record on diagnosis and specialty work is the better match. If it's a larger commercial re-roof where speed, crew stamina, and single-day turnaround matter most, High Skillz Roofing's record on fast, clean, full replacements makes it the stronger fit. Both carry high-confidence 5-star ratings, so either is a safe call: the deciding factor is what kind of flat or commercial job you're actually staring at.
Need help deciding which contractor suits your project?
Describe your roofing work once and compare quotes from qualified roofing contractor in Ontario.
Enquiries you submit through our forms may be shared with partner providers who can carry out the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based only on our published methodology and are not influenced by referral fees.
Frequently asked questions
- Which is better for a commercial flat roof leak that's hard to diagnose?
- The Roof Technician Toronto has specific praise for catching and fixing chronic leaks that other roofers missed, making it the stronger pick for a diagnosis-heavy job.
- Which is faster for a full commercial roof replacement?
- High Skillz Roofing is noted for completing full replacements in a single day with a crew that keeps pace through demanding conditions.
- Do both companies avoid upselling?
- Yes, both are praised in reviews for honest pricing and explaining work clearly without pushing unnecessary extras.
- Which has the stronger overall review record?
- High Skillz Roofing has a slightly higher composite score (94.4 vs 92.9) and more reviews (208 vs 149), though both are 5-star, high-confidence listings.