GTA Roofing Pros vs High Skillz Roofing Inc.: which roofing contractor should you call?
GTA Roofing Pros and High Skillz Roofing Inc. both turn up in North York roofing searches with near-identical five-star records, which makes them genuine alternatives for anyone hiring a roofing contractor right now. The real choice comes down to what your roof needs: a crew that hunts down problems other roofers miss and handles the insurance paperwork, or a crew that shows up on time and finishes the whole replacement in a single day. Our methodology scores both nearly identically, so the tiebreaker is fit, not the number.
The differences that matter
- Diagnosis & insurance claims. GTA Roofing Pros is called out for catching roof problems other contractors missed and for walking customers through insurance claim documentation, while High Skillz is praised for straightforward, no-upsell quoting rather than claims support.
- Same-day replacement speed. High Skillz regularly completes full roof replacements in a single day with a crew that works through summer heat with minimal breaks, a specific turnaround claim not made about GTA Roofing Pros.
- Who leads the crew. GTA Roofing Pros work is tied to named technicians Isaac and Reuven leading the crew, whereas High Skillz customers deal directly with owner Arthur on site.
- Materials and warranty. GTA Roofing Pros specifically installs GAF Certified shingles with warranty terms that matter to repeat customers, a certification not mentioned in the High Skillz summary.
- Scope of work. GTA Roofing Pros' listed scope stretches into heated cable installation and soffit/fascia repair alongside roofing, while High Skillz stays focused on replacements, targeted repairs, and storm damage response.
Side by side
- Google rating
- GTA Roofing Pros: 5 (282 reviews)
- High Skillz Roofing Inc.: 5 (213 reviews)
- Services
- GTA Roofing Pros: roof replacement installation, siding contractor, skylight contractor, roof repair
- High Skillz Roofing Inc.: roof inspection maintenance, roofing contractor, roof replacement installation, siding contractor
- Best fit for
- GTA Roofing Pros: Suspected hidden leaks, insurance-claim jobs, and full roof systems (soffit, fascia, heated cables)
- High Skillz Roofing Inc.: Straightforward replacements or repairs you want wrapped up in one day
- Who you deal with
- GTA Roofing Pros: Crew leads Isaac and Reuven
- High Skillz Roofing Inc.: Owner Arthur, directly on site
- Standout credential
- GTA Roofing Pros: GAF Certified shingle installation with warranty
- High Skillz Roofing Inc.: Same-day full roof replacement turnaround
- Verification
- GTA Roofing Pros: Google-verified
- High Skillz Roofing Inc.: Google-verified
- Composite score
- GTA Roofing Pros: 94
- High Skillz Roofing Inc.: 94
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
GTA Roofing Pros
Reuven and his crew deliver swift, attentive service for roof and soffit work across the GTA. Customers consistently report same-day or next-day completion, clear communication with photos of progress, and professional installation or repair. The team has solved long-standing leaks others missed and earns repeat business.
Reviewers praise fair pricing, courteous staff, and Reuven's responsiveness to questions. Notably, the business handles everything from emergency tarping and leak repair to full roof replacement and attic insulation, with customers citing confidence in the quality and scope of work.
High Skillz Roofing Inc.
Arthur and his team consistently respond fast to urgent leaks and complete jobs the same day or next day, with crews arriving on time, explaining work clearly, and leaving sites spotless. They handle skylight leaks, metal roof installations, flat roof replacements, and emergency storm damage with equal care, backed by fair pricing and follow-up photos that give homeowners confidence in the work.
Which should you pick?
Pick GTA Roofing Pros if
- You suspect a leak or issue that other roofers already looked at and missed
- You're filing an insurance claim and want documentation support built into the job
- You want GAF Certified shingles with warranty coverage, or need soffit/fascia or heated cable work alongside the roof
Pick High Skillz Roofing Inc. if
- You want a full roof replacement finished start to finish in a single day
- You'd rather deal directly with the owner on site than a rotating crew
- You want a plain, honest quote with no pressure to add extra work
Verdict
This isn't close on score, so pick on fit: if your roof has a problem that's already stumped one contractor, or you're navigating an insurance claim, GTA Roofing Pros' diagnostic reputation and GAF-certified installs are built for that job. If you just need a roof replaced or repaired cleanly and fast, with the owner himself running the crew, High Skillz Roofing Inc.'s same-day turnaround and no-upsell approach is the better match.
Need help deciding which contractor suits your project?
Describe your roofing work once and compare quotes from qualified roofing contractor in Ontario.
Enquiries you submit through our forms may be shared with partner providers who can carry out the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based only on our published methodology and are not influenced by referral fees.
Frequently asked questions
- Which roofing contractor responds faster to emergencies?
- Both are praised for emergency response: GTA Roofing Pros for quick same-day assessment and emergency tarping, and High Skillz for fast response to leaks and storm damage calls.
- Which one is better if I'm filing an insurance claim?
- GTA Roofing Pros specifically offers insurance claim documentation support, which is called out in customer feedback; this isn't mentioned as part of the High Skillz workflow.
- Which contractor finishes the job fastest?
- High Skillz is specifically noted for completing full roof replacements in a single day, with a crew that keeps working through summer heat.
- Do both use certified roofing materials?
- GTA Roofing Pros specifically installs GAF Certified shingles with warranty terms; no specific material certification is mentioned for High Skillz.